On this page, we discuss caselaw concerning how federal courts have treated applications to expunge federal arrests and convictions.



The 2001 decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in United States v. Dunegan, 251 F.3d 477 (3rd Cir. 2001) held that the United States District Courts lack jurisdiction to expunge federal arrests or convictions. A 2011 non-precedential opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held that expungement of records relating to arrests for federal crimes was limited to situations specified in statutes passed by Congress. That decision is Carter v. United States, 431 Fed. Appx. 104 (3rd Cir., 2011). But federal provisions that provide for expunction of arrests and convictions are extremely limited.

United States v. Schnitzer, 567 F.2d 536 (2d Cir., 1977), cert. den. 435 U.S. 907 (1978) held that, on a case-by-case basis, “expungement lies within the equitable jurisdiction of the court[.]” United States v. Douglas, 282 F.Supp.3d 275 (D.D.C., 2017), interpreted District of Columbia precedent to hold that federal courts do have equitable jurisdiction to expunge federal arrests and convictions. Note, however, that jurisdiction was never challenged in the Douglas court. A 2015 case that relied upon Schnitzer was Jane Doe v. United States of America. Doe was decided in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York. Footnote 16 in Doe gives an extended legal discussion of expungement of federal arrests and conviction.

The United States Department of Justice appealed the Doe decision to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. The Second Circuit reversed, holding that the District Court lacked jurisdiction to consider the application. A New York Times editorial discussed Doe at length on October 19, 2015, before the appeal was decided.

In semi-agreement with the Schnitzer principle is United States v. McMains, 540 F.2d 387 (8th Cir., 1976). McMains observed, however, that “The power is a narrow one, usually exercised in cases of illegal prosecution or acquittals and is not to be routinely used.” Chastain v. Kelley, 510 F.2d 1232, 1235 (D.C. Cir., 1975), holds that the power to order expungement is an instance of the general power of the federal courts to fashion appropriate remedies to protect important legal rights. The Chastain opinion cites other cases of similar holding.

The United States Supreme Court has never treated this issue directly. In view of the disparate treatment between the circuits, a decent likelihood exists that this issue can reach the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has upheld expunction of non-criminal records of administrative agencies. Cases so holding are collected in Chastain.

 A New Beginning     FAQ     Difficult Cases     Our Guarantee     Eligibility Review     Your Arrest History 

 Testimonials     “Plan B”     *** New Law ***     Court Decisions     After the Expungement     DNA 

 Mental Health Records     Child Abuse Registry     Motor Vehicle Offenses     Radio Promo     Contact Us!   



Law Offices of Allan MarainNJ and New Jersey arrested can expunge criminal records and convictions for crimes and dismissed.
Attorney and Counsellors at Law
100 Bayard Street
P.O. Box 1030
New Brunswick NJ 08903
732-828-2020
or Toll Free: 877-XPUNG-NJ
(877-978-6465)
email: Info@NJExpungements.com

Former client N.S. (file 7474) wrote: “Thank you SO much! You have been wonderful throughout the duration of the process and I am so grateful everything went well and on schedule!”

Refresh this page for a testimonial from another random client.
Click for a tsunami of testimonials from other former clients.

Expungement Lawyers in New Jersey™ and NJExpungements.com
Copyright © 2003-2018, Allan Marain, New Brunswick, New Jersey, all rights reserved.
For information, questions, or suggestions about our site, please email our webmaster.

Our privacy policy is available for your review on a separate page on this site.
Web site design by DNEBA Enterprises » Accessible and Effective Web Design.
Search engine optimization by Rank Magic.
Hosted by Westhost »When you expect more from your Web host.
Page last updated June 10, 2018, and displayed Thursday 13 December 2018, at 08:29:23 MST.


  10.0Allan Marain   Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!   [ Powered by Apache ]   Dynamic Drive provides much-valued technical assistance for attorneys at law in New Jersey court defense