On this page we discuss whether information concerning an arrest or conviction expunged by a New Jersey court must be divulged on forms and questions asked in other jurisdictions. For a concrete example, we frame our answer in terms of California law. But the information on this page applies to all other jurisdictions.

Our analysis begins with one of the New Jersey expungement statutes, N.J.S. 2C:52-27, “Effect of Expungement.” With specific exceptions, that statute states that “... the arrest, conviction and any proceedings related thereto shall be deemed not to have occurred, and the petitioner may answer any questions relating to their occurrence accordingly...”. However, N.J.S. 2C:52-27 begins with the words, “Unless otherwise provided by law...” So the first question is, whose law? New Jersey law? California law? Federal law? Was the New Jersey Legislature trying to say that other states can require divulgence of information that clearly the expungement would shield if the question were governed by New Jersey law? And must California even care about what the New Jersey Legislature may have been “trying” to say?

If the intent of N.J.S. 2C:52-27 was to allow you to deny the expunged matter on your California application, another issue then arises. Article IV, Section 1, of the United States Constitution requires states to afford “full faith and credit” to decisions of courts of other states. This Constitutional requirement is implemented by Title 28, Section 1738, of the United States Code. Expungement of a New Jersey offense is a decision of a New Jersey court. Thus it would seem that other states should recognize the expungement and give it the same effect that it would have in New Jersey.

Unfortunately, it does not always work that way in practice. Public agencies in several states instruct applicants for professional licenses to divulge prior criminal matters, even when those matters were expunged in the state in which they arose. These requirements are specified in the statutes of those other states. Section 44009 of the California Education Code considers prior criminal convictions regardless of the subsequent history of those offenses. The California Commission on Teacher Credentialing specifically requires information concerning past convictions, even after those convictions are expunged. A page on the site of the Medical Board of California discusses this issue in the context of applications for licensure in the medical field. Florida Statute 943.0585(4)(b) permits denial under oath of events expunged under Florida law, but is silent as to events expunged under the laws of other jurisdictions. Allan Marain is among the highly experienced Expungement Lawyers in New Jersey™. He can help expunge your NJ arrest and conviction record.

The United States Supreme Court has never ruled on whether such practices violate the Full Faith and Credit Clause. One United States Court of Appeals did. The Fifth Circuit held that such practices are legal. White v. Thomas, 660 F.2d 680, 685 (5th Cir., 1981), cert. den., 455 U.S. 1027 (1982), held that Texas requiring information concerning an out-of-state matter that was expunged does not violate Full Faith and Credit because Texas is not required to conform its practices to the law of other states. In the federal arena, this issue has been resolved only in the Fifth Circuit. We provide a constitutional analysis of this issue on still another page on this site.

Expungement Lawyers in New Jersey™ deplore what to now has been the prevailing treatment of this issue. However, barring a better reasoned decision in any particular location, the safer course might be to divulge the prior criminal history, even though expunged in New Jersey. Issues such as these should be presented to lawyers licensed to practice in the specific jurisdiction in question.

 A New Beginning     Eligibility Review     FAQ     Difficult Cases     Our Guarantee     Your Arrest History 

 Testimonials     “Plan B”     Recent Developments     Unreasonable Delays     Court Decisions 

 After the Expungement     DNA     Mental Health Records     Child Abuse Registry     Identity Theft 

 Traffic Offenses     Skills and Methods     Radio Promo     How Did We Do?     Retiring!     Contact Us!   

Law Offices of Allan MarainNJ and New Jersey arrested can expunge criminal records and convictions for crimes and dismissed.
Attorney and Counsellor at Law
100 Bayard Street
P.O. Box 1030
New Brunswick NJ 08903


Former client J.E.B. (file 6591) wrote: “Mr. Marain was extremely professional, he explained the process in easy to understand terms and he was very compassionate. This was very difficult for me and he handled everything in a caring, confidential manner. I only wish I had contacted him sooner, it could have made a significant difference even dating back to the original incident. Money well spent.”

Refresh this page for a testimonial from another random client.
Click for a tsunami of testimonials from other former clients.

Expungement Lawyers in New Jersey™ and NJExpungements.com
“Expungements with Dignity”
Copyright © 2003-2023, Allan Marain, New Brunswick, New Jersey, all rights reserved.
For information, questions, or suggestions about our site, please email our webmaster.

Our privacy policy is available for your review on a separate page on this site.
Search engine optimization by Rank Magic.
Disputes arbitrated by New Jersey Arbitrations, Inc. »Keeping You Out of Court.
Hosted by Westhost »When you expect more from your Web host.
Page last updated September 24, 2018, and displayed Monday 4 December 2023, at 03:17:15 MST.

  Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!   [ Powered by Apache ]   Dynamic Drive provides much-valued technical assistance for attorneys at law in New Jersey court defense